Scots are forking out thousands of pounds—some are having to use personal savings or borrow from family members—to pay for cataract procedures, for hip and knee replacements and even for rounds of chemotherapy. I hear what the cabinet secretary says, but it is a lot of words that cover up the incompetence of the Scottish National Party Government. When will he accept that, after 18 years of the SNP in charge, Scots face the reality of a two-tier health service in Scotland?